Week three of the Autumn Nations Series concluded with thrilling matches that showcased rugby’s global competitiveness, the regression of some nations and the rise of a sleeping giant. Here’s a summary of the results and their significance:
Ireland 22-19 Argentina (Aviva Stadium, Dublin)
Ireland narrowly edged past Argentina in a physical encounter marked by strong defensive work. Standout player Jack Crowley displayed composure and accurate goal-kicking. We thought that Ireland has a higher ceiling than most of the top teams on earth, but this estimation has been tempered by an unconvincing couple of performances against the All Blacks and Argentina. Los Pumas can rightfully be put along side the Springboks as World Rugby’s Men’s Team of the Year – if the voting is fair. This is the best season that Felipe Contepomi’s side has ever had, with him also probably down to challenge Rassie Erasmus as Men’s Coach of The Year.
Scotland 59-21 Portugal (Murrayfield, Edinburgh)
Scotland delivered a commanding performance, showcasing their attacking flair after being beaten by the Springboks a week before. Arron Reed shone with a double. The match underscored Scotland’s depth and readiness for tougher opposition.
England 20-29 South Africa (Twickenham, London)
South Africa’s tactical dominance over England reaffirmed their position as rugby’s reigning powerhouses. Cheslin Kolbe absolutely shredded the English defence, while the hosts failed to capitalise on the opportunities that they created having rattled the world champions at times. This defeat raised questions about England’s game management, whether it be in winning or losing positions, or indeed when a match is in the balance. As such, with three losses in a row in the series – from games that were actually within hand – confirms them as chokers under Steve Borthwick.
France 30-29 New Zealand (Stade de France, Paris)
France claimed a narrow, dramatic victory over New Zealand, cementing their credentials as a top-tier threat still intent on a maiden Rugby World Cup title. As for the visitors, it was another pulsating powerhouse performance from flanker Ardie Savea, who struggled to contain his disappointment at the end after coming up short while also praising the home team. The All Blacks might no longer be invincible, but they do remain a frightening prospect if underestimated. Unfortunately, they are on a three-match losing streak against Les Bleus.
Italy 20-17 Georgia (Stadio Luigi Ferraris, Genoa)
Italy edged out Georgia in a close-fought contest that highlighted their resilience. Paolo Garbisi’s reliable kicking proved decisive. For Georgia, the match demonstrated progress but also areas needing improvement to compete consistently at this level.
Wales 20-52 Australia (Principality Stadium, Cardiff)
Australia’s dominant performance against forlorn Wales was their most convincing of the series. Joe Schmidt’s revitalised Wallabies more than thoroughly outplayed the hosts, with Tom Wright delivering a standout display in scoring a hat-trick alongside Matt Faessler. Some of us thought that this was one game the Wallabies would sneak to avoid a Grand Slam whitewash, but now the team is 2-0 with shades of the 1984 touring squad covering this resurgent team. On the other hand, the humiliating loss exposed Wales’ paltry player depth, defensive frailties and strategic issues, with the latter falling squarely on embattled coach Warren Gatland’s shoulders. The Dragons have not won a Test match since the 2023 Rugby World Cup in France, losing a record 11 matches in a row and making a case for being the worst side the nation has ever produced.
